Manchester United vs Tottenham

Embarrassing Defeat at Old Trafford

Manchester United manager Erik ten Hag wore a haunted expression after Tottenham Hotspur handed his side an embarrassing defeat at Old Trafford. The pressure on Ten Hag has only intensified since the club decided to back him during the summer, leaving the Dutchman in a position where every poor performance invites crisis and intense scrutiny. With the latest defeat at the hands of Spurs, it seems Erik ten Hag’s time may be running out.

Highs and Lows of Ten Hag’s Tenure

Winning the EFL Cup 18 months ago and last season’s FA Cup final victory against Manchester City were among the few highlights of Ten Hag’s tenure. However, Sunday’s 3-0 loss to Tottenham at Old Trafford represents a new low point for Manchester United under his leadership.

Tottenham’s manager, Ange Postecoglou, has faced his challenges this season as well, but his side’s emphatic win over United marked their fourth straight victory since the defeat to Arsenal. In contrast, Manchester United appeared directionless and disorganized, causing growing concerns over Erik ten Hag’s ability to lead the club effectively.

Can Erik ten Hag Survive?

The biggest question hovering over Old Trafford is whether Erik ten Hag can survive in his current position. This recent defeat suggests that Ten Hag is struggling to keep his head above water, despite managing to pull back from the brink in the past. But this time, the situation feels more precarious, more definitive.

If there were any signs of defensive improvement this season, they were thoroughly extinguished by Tottenham’s clinical performance. From the very first whistle, Spurs looked determined to dominate, as evidenced by Micky van de Ven’s lightning run in the third minute that left United players trailing and set up Brennan Johnson for an easy finish.

A Shambolic Performance from Manchester United

Manchester United started the match poorly, and their performance deteriorated further as the game progressed. Spurs had numerous opportunities to extend their lead, and while they failed to capitalize in the first half, it was clear that United was struggling in all aspects of the game. The lack of structure, direction, and discipline was evident throughout the match.

After the game, Ten Hag suggested that the red card shown to captain Bruno Fernandes three minutes before halftime “changed the game.” However, it was clear that Spurs were already threatening to run riot even before Fernandes’ dismissal, and the sending-off only added to United’s misery.

Tottenham was missing their star player, Son Heung-min, due to injury. Despite his absence, Spurs outclassed United in every department, displaying quality, pace, and intent—something that Manchester United lacked entirely. There seemed to be no clear strategy or identity from Ten Hag’s squad, raising questions about his leadership and game plan.

Manuel Ugarte, Ten Hag’s recent signing, struggled to make an impact in the midfield, while Joshua Zirkzee, who was substituted at halftime, failed to show any of the cutting-edge performance that United hoped for when they signed him for £36.54m.

Premier League Struggles Continue

United currently sits in 12th place in the Premier League, having lost three of their first six matches—worrying figures that suggest Ten Hag’s time may be running out. Consecutive home defeats without scoring a goal have only added to the uncertainty surrounding his position.

The last time United suffered consecutive home league losses without scoring was under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, who was sacked shortly afterward. The fact that history appears to be repeating itself suggests that Erik ten Hag’s days may be numbered.

Tottenham’s Dejan Kulusevski alone created nine chances, the most by a visiting player in a Premier League game at Old Trafford since records began in 2003-04. The statistics only serve to highlight the decline that has occurred during Ten Hag’s reign.

Since Sir Alex Ferguson’s time at Manchester United, the club has experienced 23 Premier League defeats by three or more goals in the last 424 matches. This is more than in Ferguson’s entire tenure, when it happened just 22 times across 1,035 league games. Currently, United has only seven points after six games—matching their lowest tally at this stage of a Premier League season. They have struggled offensively, scoring fewer goals only once at this point in the 2007-08 season.

Lack of Discipline and Control

One of the most telling signs of the troubled state of affairs at Old Trafford is the lack of discipline within the squad. Following Bruno Fernandes’ red card, substitute Mason Mount received a yellow card for a reckless challenge just moments after coming on. Similarly, Lisandro Martinez cynically brought down James Maddison, highlighting a desperate and disorganized team.

If Erik ten Hag manages to survive this debacle, the upcoming fixtures do not look any easier. Manchester United will face Porto in the Europa League on Thursday, followed by a trip to Aston Villa on Sunday. With tough matches ahead, the pressure on Ten Hag will only increase.

A Grim Outlook for Ten Hag

Tottenham fans taunted Ten Hag with chants of “You’re getting sacked in the morning.” Whether that prediction becomes a reality remains to be seen. What is clear, however, is that Sunday was a dark and desperate day for Erik ten Hag—one that felt like the beginning of the end of his tenure as Manchester United manager.