Erik ten Hag

Manchester United vs Tottenham: Erik ten Hag Under Crisis

The second-half downpour mirrored the atmosphere at Old Trafford as Manchester United suffered another painful defeat, bringing more questions about manager Erik ten Hag’s future. Sunday’s dismal 3-0 loss to Tottenham left United in 12th place in the Premier League, with just seven points from their opening six games. Bruno Fernandes’ first-half red card, when they were already behind, made a bad situation worse.

Former United defender Gary Neville labeled the performance “disgusting” and “disgraceful,” while pundit Jamie Redknapp called it “embarrassing,” stating the club had hit “rock bottom.” BBC Radio 5 Live’s Chris Sutton added, “That’s the type of performance that gets the manager sacked.”

Troubling Statistics for Manchester United and Erik ten Hag

The stats further reveal Manchester United’s current struggles:

  • Seven points from six matches marks the club’s joint-lowest start to a Premier League season.
  • Only in 2007-08 have United scored fewer goals in their first six games.
  • United has now lost consecutive home league matches without scoring for the first time since Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s final two games before being sacked.
  • United have suffered 23 Premier League defeats by three or more goals since Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement, more than they had in 1,035 league games under Ferguson.

Big Decision Looms for Manchester United on Erik ten Hag

Erik ten Hag faced pressure last season but was ultimately backed by Manchester United’s owners. He led United to a third-place Premier League finish and ended the club’s six-year trophy drought by winning the Carabao Cup. However, his second season has been much more challenging. The current poor start to the 2024-25 season is adding more pressure on the 54-year-old former Ajax boss.

Robbie Savage commented on BBC Radio 5 Live, “I think they’ve got to make a big decision this week—his time might be up.” Gary Neville also criticized the performance, labeling it one of the worst under Ten Hag. The question now facing United is how much longer they can back their manager.

Jamie Redknapp added, “I just don’t see how Erik ten Hag can keep his job. He looks lost, and I don’t know how he can turn it around.”

Former United captain Ashley Young echoed the sentiment, stating, “Today has shocked me about how low they have gone. They need a crisis meeting this week.”

Erik ten Hag: United Still Together Despite Setbacks

Despite the mounting criticism, Erik ten Hag remains defiant, emphasizing the club’s unity and commitment to improvement. “I think we all made this decision to stay together, as an ownership, leadership group, staff, and players,” he said. “I think we will get better, but it takes time.”

Ten Hag argued that the red card for Bruno Fernandes changed the match, stating, “It was only 1-0. We could have made a comeback.”

Manchester United were already struggling before Bruno Fernandes was controversially sent off in the 42nd minute. The midfielder appeared to slip into a tackle on James Maddison, but referee Chris Kavanagh issued a straight red card, a decision upheld by VAR.

Fernandes disagreed with the call: “It was never a red card, in my view. I accept it being a foul, maybe a yellow, but nothing more.”

Ashley Young, speaking on Sky Sports, supported Fernandes: “I don’t think it is serious foul play—he slipped. The referee has got it wrong.”

Tottenham's Dominant Performance Outclasses United

Tottenham outplayed Manchester United from start to finish, securing a dominant 3-0 victory. Spurs recorded an expected goals value of 5.33, highlighting their superior display at Old Trafford. Even without captain Son Heung-min, who missed the match due to injury, Spurs showed attacking intent throughout.

Gary Neville called Tottenham’s performance “outstanding,” while Leon Osman added, “Spurs look like a team challenging for the top four, while United are in disarray.”

The 2024-25 season has been a rollercoaster for Tottenham under Ange Postecoglou, but this victory marks their fourth successive win in all competitions. They remain within three points of the top four and look well-positioned to challenge for a Champions League spot.

Conclusion: Erik ten Hag at a Crossroads

Manchester United’s current form raises serious questions about Erik ten Hag’s ability to steer the club forward. The loss to Tottenham is the latest in a string of disappointing results, leaving United with a decision to make. With a demanding set of fixtures ahead, the pressure is mounting on Ten Hag and his players to find solutions before the situation worsens.